Protocol
High-quality plant protein in place of red meat, for LDL cholesterol
In a meta-analysis A study that pools the numbers from several trials into one combined estimate. of 36 randomized trials (1,803 people), diets with red meat left LDL Low-density lipoprotein cholesterol, the cholesterol fraction most closely tied to plaque in the arteries. cholesterol 0.198 mmol/L higher than diets that replaced it with high-quality plant protein such as legumes, soy and nuts.
Grade C: human trials exist, but they are small, mixed or not yet repeated. This is not a finding that it does not work. How to read a grade →
At a glance
When people swapped red meat for beans, soy or nuts, their LDL cholesterol came out about 8 points lower. That is just under the size EBL needs for a B, so the letter is C. Swapping red meat for fish or chicken made no such difference.
- What was measured
- LDL cholesterol after weeks to months on the diet.
- How big
- LDL cholesterol was 0.198 mmol/L lower when plant protein replaced red meat.Read from the summary of PMID PubMed ID: the permanent number the US National Library of Medicine gives a published paper. Each one links to that paper's record on PubMed. 30958719.
- Who it applies to
- Adults in trials of weeks to months; the effect depends on what replaces the red meat.
- Safety
- None specific identified in the trials pooled.
- Compared with
- Diets in which red meat was replaced by legumes, soy or nuts.
- Certainty
- Grade C, resting on: Meta-analysis of 36 randomized trials, by comparison diet.
- What would change this grade
- Could rise to B with: Randomized trial. Who: Adults with raised LDL. Measured: LDL cholesterol and cardiovascular events. Length: At least 6 months.
- Cost
- No price recorded yet.
- Sources
- 2 studies cited on this record, listed under Sources.
- For clinicians
- A one-page summary of this record that prints with a clinician's name and practice, folds to a plain-language patient handout, and gives a chart note to paste into the patient record: Printable summary and chart note.
In a meta-analysis of 36 randomized trials (1,803 people), diets with red meat left LDL cholesterol 0.198 mmol/L higher than diets that replaced it with high-quality plant protein such as legumes, soy and nuts. That is just under EBL's 0.20 mmol/L threshold for a B on LDL, so the letter is C. Against all comparison diets combined, red meat made no difference to LDL.
Why this letter
Why this gradeGrade C, small or unreplicated trials. The reasoning, and what the grade does not cover.
Grade C on LDL cholesterol. A meta-analysis of 36 trials found LDL 0.198 mmol/L lower when high-quality plant protein replaced red meat (Guasch-Ferré et al., 2019; PMID 30958719).
WHY NOT Bthe point estimate is below the 0.20 mmol/L threshold, applied from the unrounded figure. A 2025 network meta-analysis found 0.19 mmol/L, with very low to low certainty (López-Moreno et al., 2025; PMID 40997609). Under EBL's LDL rule (November 2026), a B on LDL needs a pooled between-group change of at least 0.20 mmol/L (about 7.7 mg/dL) with a confidence interval The range the true effect probably falls in. A wide interval means the estimate is uncertain. excluding no effect; this is an EBL operating threshold taken from the lower bound of the published 'moderate' category (Schoeneck et al., 2021; PMID 33762150), not a validated clinical cutoff.
WHAT THIS GRADE DOES NOT COVERred meat against fish, poultry or carbohydrates, where the trials found no LDL benefit or the reverse, and processed meat, which is covered on the exposures page.
A grade describes the human evidence for a named use. It is not advice, and it is not a judgment on any individual prescription. How the letters are decided →
Who responds: this record's trial reading reports no subgroup that identifies who responds.
Evidence notes: meta-analysis
Endpoint The outcome a trial measures to decide whether the treatment worked, such as heart attacks, blood pressure or a symptom score. graded: LDL cholesterol (surrogate)
Last reviewed: November 2026
The trial that would change this grade.
A positive trial of this shape, supported by further trials, would move this entry to B.
Why the current trials fall short
A larger or longer pooled effect would be needed.
ClinicalTrials.gov, the public registry run by the U.S. National Library of Medicine, lists studies that are recruiting volunteers. The link below searches it for Red Meat among studies recruiting now. EBL has no relationship with any listed study and receives no payment for this link.
Dose, form and timing
Fasting LDL cholesterol.
Safety
No safety data. Each caution on this record, sorted by what it rests on.
None recorded.
None recorded.
None recorded.
None recorded.
No safety data: EBL has found no trial or report of harm for this record. That is an absence of evidence, not a finding of safety.
Grade history
How this letter has changedLatest: No. 457 · November 2026 · First graded.
New record in the food section. In a meta-analysis of 36 randomized trials (1,803 people), diets with red meat left LDL cholesterol 0.198 mmol/L higher than diets that replaced it with high-quality plant protein such as legumes, soy and nuts. That is just under EBL's 0.20 mmol/L threshold for a B on LDL, so the letter is C. Against all comparison diets combined, red meat made no difference to LDL.PMID 30958719 PMID 40997609
Every change to a letter on this site is dated and published. The full evidence log →
Sources
- Citations
- Every paper cited on this page is matched to its PubMed record on every build.
- Retractions
- None of these papers is retracted or under a journal expression of concern. PubMed is checked again on every build.
- Read against the papers
- November 2026. By a language model (AI-assisted reading), not yet reviewed by a clinician.
- Outside review
- Not yet done. No reviewer outside EBL has checked this record.
What each of these checks can and cannot show: evidence integrity.
The evidence, in fullTwo papers, each linked to its PubMed record.
Guasch-Ferré et al. (Circulation, 2019; PMID 30958719): meta-analysis of 36 randomized trials, 1,803 participants; no overall LDL difference between red meat and all comparison diets combined; relative to high-quality plant protein sources, red meat yielded lesser decreases in LDL (weighted mean difference 0.198 mmol/L, 95% CI 0.065 to 0.330); relative to fish, red meat yielded greater LDL decreases. López-Moreno et al. (Clin Nutr, 2025; PMID 40997609): network meta-analysis of 36 trials; plant proteins lowered LDL by 0.19 mmol/L (95% credible interval 0.03 to 0.36) more than red meat; certainty very low to low.
How EBL searched for the trials (1 search)
The search that was run, what it returned, and what was left out and why, so the absence of evidence can be checked as well as its presence.
("red meat"[tiab]) AND (LDL[tiab] OR cholesterol[tiab]) AND meta-analysis[pt]PubMed watch: does a new study change the grade? (nothing new)
No new paper matching the search behind this grade has been added to PubMed since November 2026.
Last run November 2026. A letter on EBL moves only after a logged review. A new paper never moves a letter by arriving: it is read, the answer is written here, and any change to the letter is published in the evidence log.
Disclosure
Educational use only · Not medical advice · EBL grades published human evidence and does not recommend treatment. Stopping a prescription is a decision for your physician.
Evidence Based Longevity, Inc. is owner-operated and edited by Arnold Sandlow, D.C., a California-licensed chiropractor. Evidence Based Longevity publishes in English only · Machine translations are not produced or reviewed by EBL for accuracy
© Evidence Based Longevity, Inc. All rights reserved
These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Any grade on this page describes the strength of published human trial evidence in the populations studied. It is not a recommendation for any individual and is not medical advice. Starting, stopping or changing any supplement or medication is a decision for your physician.
Grades move when new trials publish. A free monthly email lists every grade EBL moved, with the reason and the trial behind it: the sign-up is on the Evidence Log →